Rebecca Michaels-Walker

Rebecca Michaels-Walker is the Content Marketing Specialist at Canadian Science Publishing.

The mathematics of energy: A conversation with Marco Raugei

November 16, 2026 | 9 minute read

Imagine the simplest human-made object you can—a toothpick perhaps. How much energy did it take to make it? You might think first of the energy used by the factory to turn wood into small, useful slivers. But the energy story goes much further. There was the sunlight that powered the photosynthesis that grew the tree your toothpick used to be. The metal saw blades in the factory had to be mined, smelted and shaped, and fuel burned to power them. Maybe it was transported from a warehouse to the store in an electric vehicle; the electricity that powered it may have come from wind turbines, driven by atmospheric circulation ultimately generated by the warmth from the sun.  

If you expand your focus wide enough, and rewind time far enough, all energy can be traced back to a few fundamental sources: sunlight, the heat of the Earth’s core, and the gravitational forces that create tides.  

Energy is the currency of life and knowing exactly how much energy something “costs” is key to industry and sustainability. But the problem is that the further back you go to try to account for the ghostly trail of energy, the more uncertain the numbers become. The calculations get longer and more complex, and you have to make more and more assumptions, until you’re left with niggling uncertainties—and wondering why you’re calculating geological heat for a toothpick. If it’s hard for a single shard of wood, imagine how much more complicated it’d be for a laptop or a car.  

This is the great question of energy analysis: Where do you start (and stop) counting? We need to think about energy holistically to hold ourselves accountable for our choices and address global energy problems like climate change, but we also need to get things done, like building sustainable cities or making decisions about what type of car to drive. The tension between the ambition of a holistic view and the practicality of workable math runs through much of Dr. Marco Raugei’s work.

Marco RaugeiDr. Marco Raugei, a researcher and professor at Oxford Brookes University, is an expert in life cycle assessment (LCA), the gold standard method for energy accounting. LCAs attempt to balance breadth with specificity, tracking the energy use throughout the life of a product from manufacture to use to disposal, without attempting to trace each joule back to the sun. From his home base in London, where he conducts a large share of his research and now co–edits the journal Circularity in Built Environments, Raugei has become an ambassador for a rigorous, grounded approach, still fascinated by the deep story of energy but committed to robust calculations, determined that the numbers we use to plan our cities and energy systems actually add up. 

Your career has focused on improving Life Cycle Assessment (LCA). For those unfamiliar, can you explain what an LCA is and how they make sure we don’t “cheat” when calculating environmental impacts? 

Life cycle assessment, or LCA, is a methodology that actually dates back to the 1970s, when the oil crisis suddenly made everyone far more aware of energy use. It wasn’t called LCA back then, but researchers were beginning to develop systematic ways to look at all the energy required to produce a product or deliver a service. That’s when early methods like energy analysis and net–energy analysis started to appear. 

In the 1990s, the Society for Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry—SETAC—expanded this approach beyond energy to include other environmental impacts: toxicity, climate change, acidification, and so on. From there, LCA really grew into the de facto standard for assessing environmental impacts across everything from simple products to entire industry sectors. 

At its core, LCA is about life cycle thinking—accounting for all the energy that goes into delivering a product or service, from development to disposal. You can run an LCA on something physical, like a single toothpick, or on something intangible, like the heat needed to keep a home warm. You define the service—say, maintaining a room at 20°C year–round—and then compare different scenarios that can deliver that same service. LCA standardizes how system boundaries are drawn so that nothing gets left out arbitrarily. It helps us figure out which option is truly the most efficient overall. 

Now, LCA is rigorous and highly standardized, but it still allows some methodological flexibility. Analysts have to make certain judgment calls, and different choices may be more appropriate depending on the case study. That flexibility is intentional, but it does introduce a degree of subjectivity in selecting assumptions. A perfectly rigid system would give flawless reproducibility, but it wouldn’t adapt well across different products or systems. LCA tries to strike that balance. 

Beyond the ISO standards, LCA has also benefited from about two decades of additional initiatives aimed at harmonizing methods for specific sectors. These include Environmental Product Declarations—EPDs—and the more Euro–centric Product Environmental Footprint, or PEF, which is essentially LCA with category rules developed with industry input. 

LCA isn’t perfect—nothing is—and it’s still evolving, which is part of the excitement for me.  

 

Early in your career, you were involved in a new method called emergy analysis. Can you explain the concept of “energy memory”?  

It’s interesting you ask that because, in contrast to LCA, emergy—even though it originated around the same time, or earlier—has remained very niche, even in academia. There are far fewer researchers who use or even know about it compared to LCA. 

I became involved in emergy early in my career. When I was a PhD student more than two decades ago, my advisor was working with Dr. Howard Odum, the founder of the emergy methodology. I spent a year at the University of Florida, met Odum, attended his seminars, and became good friends with his leading successor, Dr. Mark Brown. That gave me the opportunity to really understand the method. 

The beauty of emergy is that it’s more than a methodology; it’s a philosophical approach. It attempts to represent all energy flows and carriers—fuels, natural renewable flows like sunlight, and even tidal energy—in a common denominator. Ultimately, on Earth, all energy comes from three sources: sunlight, gravitational energy (Earth‑Moon tides), and residual heat from the Earth’s mantle and core. Those three independent sources lie at the origin of everything else we use, including fossil fuels. 

Emergy tries to quantify the relationship between units of different forms of energy by tracing back all the processes that created them. For continuous flows like solar or tidal energy, that’s straightforward. For others, like fossil fuels or minerals transformed by tectonic processes, it becomes extremely complex. Emergy tries to trace the entire “memory” of energy that went into generating one unit of a resource. 

Conceptually, it’s incredibly ambitious and fascinating—like using a universal currency to measure everything. But working out accurate values for the coefficients is extremely uncertain. That uncertainty undermines practical usability when making decisions based on those numbers. 

In contrast, LCA reduces its ambition: we don’t attempt to estimate the “true” value of energy based on how long it took nature to create it. We take energy resources as they present themselves to us at present at face value, which is less philosophically exciting but far more practical. 

I was very enthusiastic about emergy for years, but eventually I stopped using it because some of the limitations are ultimately insurmountable. 

On a personal note, emergy indirectly led to my first meeting with my co‑editor‑in‑chief Naomi—we met at an emergy conference while I was on her PhD committee. Good things come from emergy! 

Circularity in Built Environments is an open access journal publishing research on circular economy innovations based on the pillars of design, technology, and materials to support sustainable built environments.

NOW OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS

In a 2023 paper, you argued that the debate between “renewable” and “non-renewable” energy is often a “counterproductive dichotomy”. Can you explain what you mean by this? 

Great question. The dichotomy I referred to wasn’t simply renewable versus non‑renewable energy but rather two factions within the sustainability community. One faction argues that renewable energy is essential and will save us. The other argues that on a finite planet, increasing energy use, whether renewable or not, will cause massive environmental damage. So renewable energy is seen as a distraction. 

I’ve often been placed in the first camp because of my work with photovoltaics and renewable energy. My papers tend to show that renewable energy can be viable, low‑impact, and capable of delivering large net energy gains. And I do think renewable energy has a major role to play in freeing us from fossil fuels. 

But I don’t disagree with the opposing faction’s main point: renewable energy is only one part of the puzzle. If we assume that abundant renewable energy means we can continue plundering resources at will, we’ll still run into shortages—metals, materials, ecosystems. That’s why circularity matters: it’s about more than energy. 

My paper tried to strike a balance between these viewpoints. Some colleagues underestimate the potential of renewable energy. Others underestimate the limits of material consumption. The truth is somewhere in between, even though the middle isn’t the most comfortable place to be. It’s probably the most controversial paper in my career. 

 

You’ve recently highlighted a “lack of harmonization” in how we measure the impact of electric cars. Why is it still so hard for a consumer to get a straight answer on exactly how much “cleaner” an electric vehicle is compared to a gas one? 

Part of the challenge is methodological. Different studies make different assumptions. As we talked about before, LCA still allows some flexibility and that can lead to differences. Harmonization efforts, like the recent Horizon Europe project on zero-emission vehicles, named  “TranSensus LCA”, are beneficial. 

But the main reason it’s so hard for consumers to get a clear message is that a highly accurate answer really depends on specific conditions, such as how much you drive per year, how many occupants the car usually has, how the region where you happen to be living and driving your car generates the electricity that powers your electric vehicle, and how that electricity mix might change over time.  

For gasoline (petrol) cars, most emissions occur when the fuel is burned in the engine. That’s easy to quantify: the more you drive, the more you emit. 

For EVs, there’s far more variability in electricity generation. For example, in Poland, most electricity is produced by burning coal, so charging your electric car there doesn’t actually get you away from fossil fuels. Electricity systems can also change over time. In the UK, coal used to provide a large share of electricity. But as of last year, the last coal-fired power plant shut down. Now the grid relies on gas, wind, and other sources, and the carbon intensity has dropped substantially, and it will likely continue to. This means that the environmental performance of an EV purchased today depends not just on the present electricity mix but also on future improvements. 

Another issue is that EVs require more energy and materials upfront, mainly due to the batteries. So if someone buys a fancy electric sports car but only takes it out two weekends a month, they may never recoup the upfront emissions. In that case, a petrol car might actually have lower lifetime impacts than an electric supercar with a huge battery pack that never leaves the garage. Most people who can afford an electric Ferrari won’t be driving it to work every day. If you want a car to show off, get a classic car that’s already amortized (perhaps a 1980s Porsche 911!) and take it for a spin every now and then!  

But for typical drivers or commuters who rack up 20–30,000 km per year, EVs offer clear benefits because the operational emissions are almost always lower than gasoline, including in countries with electricity mixes that are still improving. When you’re driving a lot, the initial upfront impacts are diluted very quickly over the course of the service life.  

If I had to give a one‑sentence summary: yes, EVs are more environmentally friendly than gasoline cars, but the details matter. 

Follow Circularity in Built Environments on Linkedin for journal updates and opportunities.

Given your expertise in electric vehicles and sustainable transport, has your own research changed the way you choose to travel every day? 

Absolutely. I don’t drive, full stop. I rely entirely on public transportation, and I’ve done so since moving to London 15 years ago. When necessary, I’ll rent a car, electric if it’s available.  

Here in London, there are plenty of charging points, and the share of electric vehicles in the city is on the rise, and you can see it just by walking outside. It’s a great change. But we can’t just switch to electric vehicles and consider our job done. Ultimately, we need to get vehicles off the road. We need to design cities for public transit, walking, and cycling.  

This is where research, like that published by Circularity in Built Environments come in. Circularity can be also intended as a way of for buildings and the built environment to be multifunctional. Imagine if all workplaces had charging stations. This would also facilitate the uptake of rideshares, reducing costs for commuters. Circularity is about the environment sure, but also about ease and efficiency. 

 

Out of curiosity, how do you feel about flying? It seems that more and more people are worrying about the environmental impact of their flights.  

This is one of my pet peeves. If you look at global statistics, a sizable share of global emissions are a result of transportation, and of that, passenger cars and private vehicles are the lion’s share. Despite this, people feel more guilty about their annual international flight than the car they drive every single day. Yes, flying produces significant emissions. But globally, aviation is only about 1.5% of total emissions. Cars are more like 25%. Which sector is more in need of a reckoning?  

Before we start obsessing over the difficult process of developing alternative aviation fuels, which are themselves problematic (for example, biofuel production is linked to deforestation), we need to get cars off the road. Robert Herndeen, one of the founders of energy analysis in the 1960s and 70s, once said that calling cars problematic is like saying superman was a decent athlete. You can’t overstate the problem of cars. 

If you’re worried about your annual holiday, you should probably be more worried about your daily commute.  

You have spent years “setting the record straight” on metrics like Energy Return on Investment (EROI). What is it about the “math of energy” that keeps you intellectually engaged after two decades in the field? 

I’m driven by a desire to counter opinions not grounded in evidence. I try to avoid unsupported statements and focus on quantified arguments. Without the maths, discussions about energy and sustainability slide into fiction.  

There’s too much “information” out there that’s driven by emotion and assumptions rather than hard evidence and hard facts. Energy and thermodynamics are what truly govern how the world works. Money pays for it, but energy is the driver. The physical limits of the planet’s resources and our efficiency (or inefficiency) in using them determine our future. My work is an attempt, however small, to help guide decisions toward a less unsustainable trajectory. 

I’m not an optimist by nature. Most environmental indicators continue to worsen despite decades of climate conferences. But I do have hope—partly because I have a 12-year-old daughter, and partly because without hope, what would we do? Still, hope alone accomplishes nothing. Only action does. 

Rebecca Michaels-Walker

Rebecca Michaels-Walker is the Content Marketing Specialist at Canadian Science Publishing.